In investing, success is often misunderstood. Many investors believe that profits are purely the result of intelligence or superior analysis. However, the real difference between amateur and professional investors lies in understanding skill vs luck in investing—and knowing how much of success comes from controllable decisions versus uncontrollable events.
Professional investors recognise that investment outcomes are shaped by both skill and luck. The challenge is not eliminating luck—because that is impossible—but learning how to reduce its impact over time through better decision-making.
Understanding Skill vs Luck in Investing
To make better investment decisions, investors must first understand what skill and luck truly represent and how they interact with each other in financial markets.
What Is Skill?
Skill refers to the part of an outcome that is under our control. It includes knowledge, experience, analysis, discipline, and decision-making ability. Skill improves through learning, practice, and reflection.
A simple way to identify skill is by asking whether the outcome can be influenced deliberately.
Can You Fail Deliberately?
If a person can deliberately fail, it means they have control over the outcome, and therefore skill plays a major role.
For example, an artist in a painting competition can intentionally spoil their work and lose. Since they control the result, their success is largely driven by skill rather than luck.
In investing, however, outcomes are not always fully controllable, which makes the role of skill more complex.
Why Improving Skill Alone Does Not Guarantee Success
Many investors assume that improving skills automatically leads to better results. While skill is important, it does not work in isolation, especially in competitive markets.
The Paradox of Skill
The Paradox of Skill explains why increasing skill does not always lead to better outcomes. As more investors become skilled, the market becomes more efficient and competitive.
When everyone improves at the same rate, individual advantages shrink, and randomness begins to dominate outcomes.
Why Markets Are More Competitive Today
Today’s investors have access to:
-
Abundant financial information
-
Advanced analytical tools
-
Education and market awareness
As a result, opportunities become harder to find, and small random events often decide success or failure.
What the Paradox of Skill Means for Investors
The paradox of skill teaches investors that success is not only about being skilled, but about where and how that skill is applied.
How Skill Levels Cancel Each Other
When equally skilled investors compete against each other, their abilities neutralise one another. In such environments, short-term results are influenced more by luck than by decision quality.
This is why even skilled investors can experience inconsistent results.
How to Reduce the Role of Luck in Investing
Although luck cannot be controlled, investors can reduce its impact by making smarter strategic choices.
Choosing Your Game Wisely
Choosing the right market or strategy is as important as skill itself. Competing in areas where you have knowledge or experience increases the influence of skill.
Competing Where You Have an Edge
Investors should focus on areas where:
-
They understand the risks clearly
-
They can evaluate outcomes logically
-
Fewer participants have deep knowledge
Having an edge reduces randomness and improves consistency over time.
Understanding Luck in Investing
Luck refers to outcomes that occur without our control. These outcomes may favour or harm investors regardless of their skill.
When Luck Dominates Outcomes
Luck plays a larger role when outcomes depend on unpredictable events such as news, market sentiment, or macroeconomic changes.
The Lottery Example Explained
A lottery winner cannot deliberately lose because the outcome is entirely random. Since the person has no control over the result, success is purely driven by luck.
Some investment outcomes resemble this randomness, especially in the short term.
Is Investing Skill or Luck Driven?
Investing does not fall entirely into one category. It is neither purely skill-based nor purely luck-based.
Why Investing Is Not Pure Skill
Investments involve future uncertainties. Even well-researched companies can fail due to unforeseen events, making outcomes uncertain despite strong analysis.
Why Investing Is Not Pure Luck
Investors can influence results by choosing assets carefully, managing risk, and following disciplined processes. This shows that skill plays an essential role over the long term.
When Skill Plays a Bigger Role in Investing
Skill becomes more influential when investors operate in environments where inefficiencies exist.
Competing Against Weak or Inefficient Markets
Markets with less informed participants allow skilled investors to make better decisions and achieve consistent outcomes. In such cases, success is closer to skill than luck.
When Luck Plays a Bigger Role
In highly competitive markets, luck has a stronger influence on short-term results.
Highly Competitive and Efficient Markets
In efficient markets where many skilled participants compete, small unpredictable events can significantly affect outcomes. In these situations, focusing on long-term processes becomes essential.
Psychological Biases That Distort Investment Decisions
Human psychology often interferes with our ability to correctly judge skill and luck.
Outcome Bias
Outcome bias occurs when investors judge decisions solely based on results rather than the quality of the decision itself.
Focusing on Process Over Results
A good decision can produce a bad outcome, and a bad decision can produce a good outcome. Evaluating the process instead of the result helps investors avoid false confidence or unnecessary fear.
Narrative Fallacy
Narrative fallacy occurs when investors create stories to explain outcomes, even when randomness is involved.
H4: Why Humans Create False Stories
Humans naturally seek patterns and explanations. This tendency can lead investors to misinterpret results and make flawed future decisions.
Key Takeaways for Investors
-
Investing outcomes are a mix of skill and luck
-
Skill matters most in the right environment
-
Luck dominates in highly competitive markets
-
Focusing on process improves long-term success
-
Avoid psychological biases while evaluating results
Final Thought on Skill vs Luck in Investing
You do not need to be smarter than everyone in the market.
You only need to be smarter within the game you choose to play.
By choosing the right environment, developing strong processes, and respecting the role of luck, investors can improve their chances of long-term success.
